Thriving Online with Unclear Guidelines
It is only when the routines break down, when the guidelines are unclear, when no one can tell us what to do, that we make real choices and become the creators of our own lives, communities, and futures. Then we become the agents of our own fate. These moments can be as frightening as they are exhilarating.
Marshall Ganz, “What is Public Narrative?” 2008
Every day, I can wake up and turn on my iPhone, check my Twitter feed, update my facebook page, and send an e-mail with the glow of the 3.5 inch screen brighter than the morning light, before even rolling out of bed. I can choose to spend my day searching for new apps, completely immersed in the world of digital technology in countless ways while I carry on with my daily chores, face-to-face conversations, and lesson planning. Or, I can take a deep breath, think about my intentions and goals for the day, and monitor myself with mindful use of technology.

Healy is an interesting woman. She has extensive experience in the classroom and she is a thorough researcher. Her conclusions are most thought-provoking. Her books should be required reading for all teachers — and parents of young children. I will be most interested to read what you think!
Just ordered it. I keep going back and forth, but never straying too far in either direction of the argument, as I continue to read great books and articles on tech.
Thanks for clearing that up. But I still would love to read your take on Healy’s book!
Who thinks they are the best things since sliced bread?! Hardly me!
I know that it is a massive challenge to figure out what technologies to use and how to use them, but it is foolish to ignore the fact that if we don’t educate our kids (older students) how to navigate the digital world, we’ve got even more ignorance coming down the pike.
I agree, kids in early years should have very limited tech. use. Only when the brain is more developed do i think it’s more practical and safe to start encouraging mindful tech. use. I guess I’ll have to go through these choices as a parent some day…
I wish you would read Jane Healy’s “Failure to Connect” and let us all know your take on it. She has serious reservations about the efficacy of using technological devices inthe schools — especially in the early years. You seem to think they are the best thing since sliced bread!
It is really tough to figure it out, because the system is so far behind. Too much of our district PD is still focused on improving scores on old-school, pen and paper tests, rather than exploring the rich possibilities inherent in digital reading and writing.
I, too, am glad I didn’t grow up with all the distractions children of the cell phone era accept as normal. You nailed it with the constant inane crap that passes as communication.
I am also struggling with how to use this technology in a meaningful way in my HS classroom, with little PD available right now to show me how. What to do?
So, I started my own blog. Just. Enjoy your thoughtful prose
Thanks, Jacqui. It’s an issue that has bothered me for years. We follow along blindly behind our technology seldom asking why we are doing so or where we are going! I have blogged about this. Thanks for the response.
Interesting insight, Hugh.
I like your take on this and hope you can make it happen!
🙂 I am only a consistent reader because you consistently write thoughtful posts! Keep it up!
Thanks for being such a kind and consistent reader! You really should check out Net Smart–outstanding book…
Hugh, understand your point, but I guess I’m focusing on individual consumer choices with regards to our day to day lives.
As far as the technological imperative, it’s scary. As many great tech. developments as there are, there are just as many that as destructive and superfluous. Futurists scare me.
“We can reclaim the sense that we–and not technology–are the impetus behind evolving culture.” With all due respect, I doubt there was a time when we were in control of our technical prowess; I don’t think “reclaiming” it is an issue. There is every reason to think that we are in the grips of what Jacques Ellul in 1950 called “the technological imperative.” If it can be done it will be done — with no questions asked. (His first clue was WWI and the topper was the Atom bomb.)
I love this as usual. I am so grateful to you and inspired by you that you are trying to think through this. Much is still to be learned about all this, but it is great that you are being so intentional about this. Thanks for another excellent post!